Should we buy animals from a pet store?


Summary

Would banning the sale of animals in pet stores improve animal welfare? Or could it actually make things worse?

Pet stores are often the target of criticism from animal welfare campaigners, yet much of that criticism overlooks the valuable role good stores play in responsible pet keeping. From helping customers choose a suitable species to providing ongoing support, knowledgeable staff can prevent common husbandry mistakes, identify potential welfare issues and, when necessary, refuse a sale.

We explore the findings of a Norwegian study into the practices of pet store employees, and consider why stores attract so much criticism while private and online sales receive far less scrutiny.

We also discuss the importance of licensing, inspection and public accountability, and explain why banning pet store sales risks driving trade underground, to less visible and less regulated channels.

Of course, not all pet stores are good, so we explain how to tell the difference.

Ultimately, an animal’s welfare is not determined by where it is sold, but by the people and practices behind the sale. If we’re serious about improving animal welfare, our priority should be to manage welfare standards wherever animals change hands.

What do you think?

About the contributors:

Luise Boye Sprechler: “Hi! Am I having two guinea pigs?” Live commodities in a shop – Interpretation of animal sales regulations in Norwegian pet shops. Applied Anthrozoology Project Report, University of Exeter, 2023
Sprechler, Luise Boye. "Butikksalg av dyr." Pet Scandinavia, vol. 2023, no. 3, 2023, pp. 4–7.


Tony Wigley: founder of Responsible Reptile Keeping (RRK), director at The Pet Charity, board member of the Reptile & Exotic Pet Trade Association (REPTA) and a member of the Pets Canada Advocacy Committee, with decades of experience in exotic pet keeping, journalism and international advocacy with governments and organisations around the world.

Svein Fosså: biologist, author and international advocate for responsible pet keeping, serving as President of the European Pet Organization (EPO) and Secretary General and Chairman of the Norwegian Pet Trade Association (NZB).

Charles Thompson: General Secretary of the Reptile & Exotic Pet Trade Association (REPTA) and former owner of specialist reptile store Snakes ’N’ Adders, with more than 25 years of experience in the reptile industry, specialist retail and responsible pet keeping advocacy.

Sandy Moore: President and CEO of the Pet Advocacy Network (PAN) and former President of Segrest Inc, with more than 30 years of experience in the pet and aquatics industries, sustainable animal trade and government affairs.

Cecilia Dannborg Wilson: Chair of ZOORF, the Swedish Pet Trade Association, and a former pet store owner with extensive experience in specialist pet retail and pet industry advocacy.

Transcript

The question of whether people should buy animals from a pet store, or whether stores should be selling animals at all, is raised regularly, and behind these questions is usually a sincere concern for animal welfare, which every sensible person will share.

It's easy to imagine pet stores are somewhere that animals are simply sold over the counter, but the reality is far more complex.

For many new owners, their petkeeping journey begins with a conversation with a knowledgeable member of staff at a pet store.

And every day, pet store staff spend time with customers explaining the needs of different species, why certain animals are not suitable for everyone, and how to provide appropriate food, housing, healthcare, and responsible ownership.

Staff at a good pet store will ask about your experience, your expectations, your available space, your budget, and the long-term commitment questions.

From there, they may recommend a more suitable species, or advise you that an animal is not right for you at all, and sometimes they'll simply refuse a sale.

Ultimately, the new owner's relationship with the pet store almost always continues long after the customer leaves the shop, if an animal stops eating perhaps, behaves unexpectedly, or appears unwell. The store is often the first place an owner turns for help and advice.

That means knowledgeable staff play an important first-line triage role. They may identify a problem with temperature, lighting, diet, or some other aspect of husbandry, and offer immediate helpful advice. And crucially, they can recognise when the animal needs to go to a vet.

Now, a pet store isn't a substitute for veterinary care, of course, but it is the first place many keepers look for good advice, and that advice can prevent a relatively simple husbandry problem from becoming a serious welfare issue.

We should remember that the people who work in pet stores do so for the same reasons their customers visit them, because they love animals.

From the moment an animal arrives at the store, the staff are responsible for its care. They look after it, monitor its health, and learn about its individual needs.

They want to see it placed in a good home, because they're morally and ethically compelled to make sure the animal is well cared for.

But there's also a basic commercial reality that's often overlooked. A responsible pet business depends on healthy animals and satisfied customers returning for advice and supplies over many years. Selling an unhealthy animal, or setting customers up to fail, is neither ethical nor is it a sustainable business model.

And this responsibility isn't only moral and commercial, it's also a legal responsibility. Pet stores must comply with the animal welfare and trading laws in the area where they operate, and responsible staff will refuse a sale when they believe an animal will not receive appropriate care.

In 2023, a Norwegian anthrozoologist examined how this worked in practice through interviews with employees at Norwegian pet stores. She found that staff had a strong understanding of the law and actively applied it when deciding whether a sale should proceed. Customers were refused a sale when staff believed an animal would not be provided with a suitable home. And our conversations with pet store staff in other parts of the world tell us much of the same story.

The study also found that pet store employees possessed a high level of professional knowledge and often developed strong personal attachments to the animals in their care.

At the same time, they expressed frustration that pet stores often receive criticism while the rapidly growing private and online trade is far less regulated and far less visible.

Understandably, people react strongly when they hear about animals not being properly cared for and action against poor animal welfare is something we need more of, not less.

Of course, there are a minority of pet owners, breeders and pet stores who fail to care for their animals properly. These problems must be taken seriously.

But those failings should not lead us to judge the millions of people who do care for their animals responsibly or the many dedicated pet store staff who care for their animals and guide customers towards responsible keeping.

Here's the key take home point I'd like you to remember. Good animal welfare is not determined by the sales channel. A shop, a breeder, a private seller can act responsibly or irresponsibly. The label alone tells us very little. It's the people and the practices behind the welfare outcomes that are more important.

So we must instead ask an important question. How can we ensure good animal welfare when animals change ownership?

In many parts of the world, pet stores are the most closely regulated and visible sales channel for companion and hobby animals. They're usually licensed, inspected by the authorities and held to account if they do not meet specific welfare standards.

They also operate in full public view. Every day, customers can see how the animals are housed and cared for, and few other sales channels offer the same level of visibility and accountability.

Certainly, private animal sales are also an important part of animal keeping, and many responsible breeders do an outstanding job. However, private sellers are invariably subject to less scrutiny and less routine oversight than pet stores, particularly when selling only occasionally.

It's often difficult for a buyer to know whether a private seller is a knowledgeable and responsible animal keeper, or someone with limited experience and poor intentions.

If the aim is to improve animal welfare, we should discuss how to achieve this across every sales channel, rather than simply weakening those that are already regulated, inspected, and visible to the public.

So to answer the question, yes, a good pet store is one of the best places to buy an animal, particularly for the new keeper, but the important word here is ‘good’.

So how do we know a good pet store?

Well, a good pet store will ask questions before agreeing the sale. They'll be willing to refuse an unsuitable purchase. They'll explain the animal's adult size, lifespan, and the likely costs involved in keeping it. They'll provide accurate, species-specific care information. They'll discuss the animal's origin and feeding history. And you'll be able to see that the animals are kept in clean, appropriate, temporary accommodation. They'll encourage customers to set up the animal's permanent enclosure in advance. They'll offer support after the sale. They'll recommend an appropriate vet when it's necessary. And they'll avoid pressure selling or impulse purchases.

And there are also ways to identify a less-than-ideal pet shop. Warning signs include staff that are unable to answer basic questions, sick or injured animals on display, dirty enclosures or obvious husbandry failures, animals being sold with unsuitable equipment, no interest in who is buying the animal or how it will be kept, or making it difficult to establish where the animal came from.

When it comes to animal welfare, we should be united by the same objective, and that is animals living good lives.

Banning the sale of animals in pet stores will not achieve that. In fact, it often leads to exactly the opposite, as sales revert to unobserved or underground channels.

Instead, we know that better welfare can be achieved through knowledgeable sellers, informed owners, effective regulation and higher competency across every channel by which animals change hands.

And that is something every animal lover can get behind.

I'm Tony Wigley, and this is Responsible Reptile Keeping.

Next
Next

The real problem with 'Monsters of God'